Performance Fee Controversy in the Finance Industry

Performance fees in investment management are additional fees charged by investment managers based on the performance of the investment portfolio they oversee. Unlike traditional management fees, which are a percentage of total assets under management, performance fees are directly tied to the investment results achieved by the manager. The purpose of performance fees is to align the interests of the investment manager with those of the investors. If the manager performs well and generates positive returns, they receive an extra fee. Conversely, if the manager underperforms, they may earn a lower fee or no fee beyond a base management fee.

The structure of performance fees typically includes the following elements:

1. High-Water Mark – This means the manager is only entitled to performance fees if the investment’s net asset value surpasses its previous highest value. This prevents managers from receiving fees for merely recovering losses after a period of underperformance.
2. Performance Period – Usually an annual, semi-annually, or quarterly timeframe over which the manager’s performance is evaluated, and fees are calculated accordingly.
3. Performance Benchmark – A predefined market index or relevant measure used to determine whether the manager has outperformed. If their performance exceeds the benchmark, they may earn a performance fee. This benchmark is also called the “hurdle rate”.
4. Performance Fee Calculation – The fee is often a percentage of the “outperformance” above the benchmark or high-water mark.

Performance fees are commonly found in hedge funds, private equity funds, and certain actively managed funds. They are more prevalent in alternative investments (e.g., hedge funds, private equity), where managers have more flexibility and can potentially achieve higher returns.

However, performance fees can be controversial due to several reasons:

1. Misalignment of Interests – Managers might take on excessive risk to chase higher returns and earn larger fees, potentially putting investor capital at risk. Managers may engage in aggressive or speculative trading to maximise returns, which could lead to higher volatility.
2. High Costs – Performance fees can substantially increase the overall cost of investing, particularly during strong market periods.
3. Complexity and Lack of Transparency – The calculation of performance fees can be complex, making it challenging for investors to fully understand the fee structure.
4. Benchmark Selection – The choice of benchmark can be subjective, allowing managers to select benchmarks that are easier to outperform.
5. Short-Term Focus – Performance fees might encourage managers to prioritise short-term gains at the expense of long-term sustainability.

Due to these reasons, regulators and investors have scrutinised performance fees. Some investors have sought out products with simpler fee structures or negotiated lower performance fees. Calls for increased transparency and better alignment with investor interests have also been made.

Before investing in funds with performance fees, it’s crucial for investors to thoroughly understand the fee structure (e.g., a reasonable balance between the base fee and performance fee), potential investment risks, and the ability of the manager to make informed decisions in line with their mandate.

Where to from here?

Research IP currently has over 300 reports for managed funds available in the New Zealand market, as well as a range also available in Australia. The initial coverage also includes all default, balanced, and growth KiwiSaver offerings. Coverage of funds and data points is expanding daily.

• The RIPPL Effect reports are also available on interest.co.nz.
• You can find our research embedded at the point of sale on the new investment platform Flint Wealth.
• We announced a new partnership for Research IP in New Zealand with interest.co.nz at The RIPPL Effect – The future starts here – Research IP (research-ip.com)

Looking for something in particular or have some feedback? Please reach out to one of the RIPPL team

Research IP delivers high quality investment fund research and consultancy services to financial advisers, charities & NFPs and the broader financial services industry. Our experience spans well over 20 years working directly across the multiple facets of finance, so we understand the key drivers and challenges for managers, as well as the impact for investors and the broader industry.

We strive to give you the best information, so you can help your clients make better decisions, and feel more confident about doing business with you. We believe that not only can everybody win, everybody should.

Reach out to us today about your research and consulting needs, and how to make the data work for you, and your clients.

Would you like to see research on a Managed Fund? Then enquire here.

Photo credits: Research IP, lionvision (Getty Images)